In East Elmhurst, a proposed mental health crisis facility for youth has ignited a wave of fear and misinformation among residents. Nearly 1,000 people have signed a petition opposing the conversion of a former Catholic convent into a center aimed at providing short-term respite for children and teenagers struggling with mental health issues.
Key Takeaways
- Nearly 1,000 signatures on a petition against the mental health center.
- The facility will serve youth aged 8-17, not adults.
- Miscommunication regarding the facility’s purpose has fueled community fears.
- Local officials emphasize the need for clarity and transparency.
Background of the Facility
The Our Lady of Fatima parish has decided to convert a former convent located at 25-56 80th St. into a facility operated by YAI, a non-profit focused on mental health and disability services. The Children’s Crisis Residence is set to open in January 2026 and will cater to young individuals aged 8 to 17, providing them with a safe space to cope with issues such as bullying, disabilities, and emotional trauma.
Community Concerns
Despite reassurances from YAI and local officials, many residents remain skeptical. The initial lease agreement included language referring to "chemically dependent individuals," which led to fears that the facility might serve adults with addiction issues. YAI has since clarified that this language was mistakenly included and is working to amend it.
Residents have expressed extreme concerns, fearing that the facility could eventually house not only adults with addictions but also individuals labeled as "criminally insane" or sex offenders. These claims have been categorically denied by YAI and the Diocese of Brooklyn, which has confirmed that the facility is strictly for youth under 18.
Miscommunication and Mistrust
The controversy has been exacerbated by what many residents describe as inconsistent communication from YAI and the parish. Initial descriptions of the facility’s purpose shifted over time, leading to confusion and mistrust within the community.
Mike Pinto, a member of the parish council, emphasized the need for clear stipulations in the lease to ensure that the facility will never serve adults or individuals with criminal backgrounds. He pointed out the facility’s proximity to Our Lady of Fatima Catholic Academy, raising concerns about the safety of children attending the school.
Recent Developments
The situation escalated following the arrest of a church staff member accused of sexually abusing a teenage girl, further eroding trust among residents. At a recent North Queens Homeowners Civic Association meeting, many residents voiced their concerns, feeling that they had not been given adequate opportunities to express their views.
As of mid-May, the online petition opposing the facility had garnered nearly 950 signatures, with an additional 250 residents signing a written version.
Calls for Clarity
Local officials, including Assembly Member Jessica González-Rojas, have met with YAI to discuss the project and emphasize its intended purpose. González-Rojas noted that the center aims to provide a safe alternative to emergency rooms for youth in crisis, offering counseling and stability in a supportive environment.
Ramses Frias, a Republican candidate for City Council District 25, acknowledged the widespread concern among residents, particularly regarding the facility’s proximity to the school. He stated, "People are scared because of how close this is to the school."
YAI has committed to transparency and has engaged with local officials and community members to address concerns. A spokesperson reiterated that the lease clearly outlines the facility’s purpose as a temporary residence for children in crisis, aiming to provide a safe and supportive environment for youth in need.
